spot on
hehe, just realised, i think i'm giving all ur tunes exactly the same ratings. so, let me examine why...
originality - i think a 10 is almost unreachable, simply because i will always recognise elements of other music in tunes, is not a bad thing.
diversity - hmm, dunno why i give 8, maybe i'm being a bit unfair. maybe it's because ur tunes flow so well that they don't seem to be massively diverse although the mixture of styles within a piece should maybe be considered more by me.
clarity - 10 every time because i am jellyous about how well everything sits in ur mix. this is 1 aspect of my music i have a constant battle with. i think i need to take a course in mastering or read a book or summin.
effort - i dunno how long it takes u to make these gems but i'm guessing u don't have to try too hard. and also maybe it will encourage u to try harder:)
overall - straight 10's? coz i love all the stuff i've heard so far by u, gonna take a brake now and listen to some more another day, i'm hungry.
;ped